Ask most people in Lake Forest what happens over Labor Day weekend and they will say the same thing: the Art Fair on the Square. It is the one everybody already knows, the one that has been filling Market Square with easels and folding chairs for seven decades. What most residents do not track as closely is that a second, much larger-by-attendance festival runs the same weekend in Mettawa, and this year the two events share exactly one calendar day.
That single overlapping day changes how the weekend actually works, and it is worth mapping out before Friday hits.
Sunday Is the Only Day You Get Both
The Deer Path Art League's 71st Art Fair on the Square runs Sunday and Monday, September 6 and 7, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. at Market Square. The fair is juried, draws roughly 130 artists from across the country, and carries a $3,000 prize purse, all inside a footprint historically built to pull in about 20,000 people over the two days.
Taste of Serbia, hosted by St. Basil of Ostrog Serbian Orthodox Church on North Bradley Road in Mettawa, runs Saturday and Sunday, September 5 and 6, noon to 10:30 p.m., with $5-per-car admission. It is one of the larger ethnic festivals in Lake County by the parish's own description, and 2026 adds a new act to the Saturday lineup, Morgan Street Jazz, alongside the returning folk dance lessons and the tambura sets that run most of both afternoons.
Line the two calendars up and there is exactly one day, Sunday, September 6, when both are running. Saturday belongs to Taste of Serbia alone. Monday, Labor Day itself, belongs to the Art Fair alone. If you have been assuming you could casually do both whenever you had a free afternoon this weekend, Sunday is actually the only afternoon that works, and even then you are choosing between a downtown art fair that ends at 5 p.m. and a Mettawa festival that runs until 10:30.
Two Very Different Festivals, Not a Bigger Version of One
Part of why this catches people off guard is that the two events do not feel like variations on a theme. The Art Fair is a downtown, walkable, juried arts show inside the U-shaped courtyard of Market Square, the 1916 Howard Van Doren Shaw building that was designed around cars pulling in rather than pedestrians strolling through, with a clock tower on one side and a sundial tower on the other facing the old train station. You walk it in an afternoon, browse booths, maybe buy something, and leave.
Taste of Serbia is parish-run, car-based admission, and built around a full slate of programming rather than browsing: fire truck visits for kids, folk dance lessons twice a day, a priest's cultural presentation inside the church itself, and a raffle with a $1,000 top prize. It runs later into the evening and rewards showing up hungry rather than showing up to shop. Treating it as a smaller cousin of the Art Fair undersells what is actually a full evening out.
The Dinner Plan Changed This Year, Not Just the Festival Calendar
Here is the part that makes 2026 specifically different from past Labor Day weekends: the restaurant options around both events shifted this year too.
Deer Path Inn's century-old English Room, the dining room that had anchored the historic resort's identity for 97 years, is gone. In its place is The Brasserie, which opened earlier this year with brass accents, marble-topped tables, and hours that start at 6 a.m. on weekdays and run through 10 p.m., covering breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner, and dessert in one space. Deer Path Inn general manager James Barnett described the room as designed around conversation, a deliberate departure from the more formal English Room it replaced.
A few minutes away, chef Bruno Abate, who built Tocco in Winnetka before this, brought his Follia concept to Lake Forest this year, an elegant Italian dining room with a courtyard patio that guests specifically call out as one of the better warm-weather seats in town. Reservations are recommended, since the room fills even when open tables look available from outside.
That matters for festival weekend specifically because the old default, walking into whatever Market Square shop had a table free, is no longer the only option within a short drive of downtown. If you are coming off the Art Fair Sunday afternoon and want a sit-down dinner that is not a repeat of every other Labor Day, this year gives you two genuinely new rooms to try instead of the same rotation.
Closer to Citadel Theatre on Waukegan Road, the older standbys have not gone anywhere. Piero's has been the pizza fallback in that stretch for years, and it now has company from Little Tail Sports Bar & Grill, a newer arrival at 840 South Waukegan that turned out to be more of a full dining room than the sports-bar name suggests, with large-screen TVs in one room but enough quiet dining space in another to work for a pre-theater dinner. If your Labor Day weekend plans include a Citadel show rather than either festival, that corner of town has more options than it did even a year or two ago.
September Doesn't Slow Down After Labor Day
The festival weekend is the loudest thing on the calendar, but it is not the last thing. Citadel Theatre's 12th Annual Fundraising Gala is set for Saturday, September 26, at 830 Green Bay Road, and the following day, Sunday, September 27, brings Eureka Day at Citadel Theatre, a family-oriented fall tradition with games and activities for all ages. Between those two dates and the Labor Day festivals, Lake Forest runs two distinct community gatherings inside the same month, three weeks apart, one built around dinner and a fundraiser and one built around kids and an open house feel.
For anyone mapping out the rest of September, that gives you two natural bookends: the festival weekend to open the month, and the Citadel Theatre weekend to close out its final Saturday and Sunday.
Planning the Actual Weekend
If you are trying to fit real logistics around all of this, here is how the days actually break down:
- Saturday, September 5: Taste of Serbia only, noon to 10:30 p.m., North Bradley Road in Mettawa, $5 per car, with the new Morgan Street Jazz set added to this year's afternoon lineup.
- Sunday, September 6: The one day both events run. Art Fair on the Square, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. at Market Square, and Taste of Serbia continuing into the evening in Mettawa.
- Monday, September 7 (Labor Day): Art Fair on the Square only, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Anyone who wants to hit both festivals without choosing has that single Sunday window, and probably wants to plan the Art Fair for morning or early afternoon before heading out to Mettawa for the evening food and music, rather than the reverse.
None of this requires any decision bigger than where to eat and which festival to prioritize on the one day both are running. But it is the kind of detail that separates a weekend you plan well from one where you show up at Market Square at 6 p.m. wondering why the fair is already closed.
For homeowners thinking further ahead than this particular weekend, whether that means understanding how a downtown address near Market Square compares to a lot further out toward Mettawa, or what a full-service renovation looks like for a home near either festival footprint, Andra O'Neill and her team bring the same kind of ground-level familiarity with Lake Forest to real estate that this weekend's calendar takes to plan. Reach out when you're ready to talk through what's next.